Mashup Of The Same Genre’s

I think a good mashup simply depends on what the artist does with it.

Anything is possible…

A mashup of the same genre can work wonders or be a total flop…same for cross gender…i mean genre mashups. You don’t only need to stick to one pella or one instrumental or whatever.

I tend to favour ones that have the producer’s own element weaved within them (be it beats or glitches or cramming as many different musical references as possible within 3 minutes)

It’s kinda "horses for courses" really.
There are great cross genre and same genre tracks. Equally there are some abominations around in both types.

Imagination is the key. Sometimes a random idea works wonders.

Same genre mash ups tend to be the easier ones to work with as, usually, they are Instrumental + Acapella = mash up.

Personally I prefer Mash Ups that have had a bit thought put into them.
Inventive edits, additional production, vocal re-arrangements that sort of thing. But saying that somtimes the most simple ideas work the best.

Personall opinion is the main thing, like all thing musical.

I don’t think there should be a "blue print" to how mash ups are made they either work or they don’t